Some pretty big statements made, gentlemen. Pretty big.
"Fair to middlin'. Yep one good playoff run, one good regular season. That is it." - Batdad
One GREAT playoff run and one GREAT regular season. Making the 7th game of the Cup Final is not just "good" and neither is winning the most competitive division in hockey. Keep in mind that Sutter has been running things for only 2 full seasons, one of which was the Cup run and the other was the NW division title season. I have no delusions about how naff we were before that (but I was still at the Saddledome every other night, so don't call me a bandwagoner at any point. Not that anyone has, I'm just saying ahead of time).
"Anyone ever see how Luongo did in the World Cup semi final when Brodeur got hurt, under thousands of pounds of pressure? Oh yeah, right he was amazing!" - Batdad
I remember that and Luongo terrified me. Every shot I thought he was going to let squeeze through him he looked so awkward controlling rebounds and absorbing pucks. He got the job done and good for him but he certainly didn't impress me.
"On to the Flames: Calgary has a team that plays a style that reminds me alot of the Dallas Stars cup winning team. 1 man in 4 at the blueline. Then when the 1 man gets beat, 4 at the Flames blue line. Dump out, dump in." - Batdad
How closely do you watch the Flames? I'm not going to try to argue that they play an exciting offensive brand of hockey (when they try to they lose, recent trip through Toronto and Montreal case in point) but they work hard for the puck in all three zones and are always physical (who doesn't enjoy watching Dion Phaneuf level a Sean Avery or beat up a Bill Guerin?). What's more exciting than winning? The Flames don't care about putting on a show for anybody and the fans don't care if they get one or not, they want to see the team win. Call them boring all you want, it's not going to bother a real Flames fan.
"Calgary had some success with rubbish hockey, but if even Lemaire is playing some fire wagon stuff...The Flames? No hope. They need to get with the program or Sutter/Playfair will end up in the same spots as Clarke/Hitchcock" - Batdad
Calgary's played a really clean game so far as far as obstruction goes. Compared to Vancouver anyhow. The Flames are 12th in PIM and the Canucks are 4th. I'll let the stats speak for themselves. Get with what program? I'm amazed at the short memories of some people. Calgary started 4-7-1 last season in October. They finished 3rd overall in the conference. What program is there to get with? The winning early then tanking down the stretch program that the Canucks subscribe to? Meanwhile, Clarke and Hitchcock have spent years in Philly and every year was supposed to be a championship year. Same story with Brian Burke and Marc Crawford. If Sutter/and Playfair go another four or five years without converting, they're justifiably out but their regime has just begun, Sutter has brought nothing but success, and it's much too early to say anything about Playfair. They're not going anywhere, with or without "the program".
"Speaking of Calgary I've always thought they were the most overrated team in ohhh I dunno maybe a few decades? They won't even sniff the playoffs let alone get back to make another run." - Minstrel
Overrated? Like 03-04's Canucks? That was supposed to be the year for them if I recall. Or overrated like the Penguins before last season? Weren't they supposed to challenge for the Cup? At least the Flames held a winning record. If anything I thought they got LESS respect last season until they proved themselves because so many people expected another Anaheim (03) or Carolina (02) or Buffalo (99) or Washington (98) or Florida (96). They made it back to the playoffs so it's hard to call them pretenders.
"And if they weren't overrated enough as it was they bring in Tanqueray as The Answer to their innate lack of goal scoring? And you say that Luongo isn't worth the money?? At least his stats were all his own and impressive considering that he was relied on to stop 60 shots a night to give Florida even a fighting chance. What has Tanqueray done? Beside be fortunate enough to land on a line with BOTH Joe Sakic AND Peter Forsberg at one point in his stat padding career?" - Minstrel
Tanguay is getting better but he's obviously not the player Flames fans hoped he'd be so far. I do think that his contract was offered too early and for too long but that's the only way Sutter could sign him. More importantly, he spent pretty much all of last season on a line with Ian LaPerriere and Brett Clark. Look at THEIR stats and we'll ask ourselves who's being inflated by whom. One more time. If Luongo were that great, he'd have taken the Panthers to AT LEAST a winning season.
"Even Iginla could score with the linemates the green glass player has had the fortune of lining up with."
I really hope you're not cracking on Jarome. Not that I would do anything about it

Jarome is a true leader, he wins faceoffs, he plays (very well) on the PK, he's a two-time Richard winner and (seriously) an excellent human being. His production might have been down last year but I'll refer you to a guy called Steve Yzerman who scored over 100 points a season for a losing Red Wings club until some nobody coach Scotty Bowman got him playing a more defensive role. Yzerman's point totals dropped significantly, but the team started to win. Winning is what matters to Jarome, not goals. If he has to be the guy to score them he will (he pretty much single-handedly took the Flames to game 7 against the Ducks, I admit that the guys were tremendously lackluster once Bryzgalov started to frustrate them a little bit), but the team always comes first with Jarome.
"maybe Kipper should give Luongo a call because he looks so very very ordinary this year." - Minstrel
Maybe. Or maybe I'll bring up, one more time, the Flames (and Kipper's) weak opening last year. Then I'll mention that Kiprusoff went on from a 4-7-1 start to win 8 in a row and lead the league in GAA and shutouts, place second in wins and third in save % before taking home the Vezina and the Jennings. He looked pretty bad the first few games last year too, is what I'm saying.
Call the Flames mediocre all you want. We'll see you at the end of the year.