batdad wrote:Ice Timer--Swedes don't know how to play D? Better go back and look at the Norris Trophy Winners list and at the Selke trophy runner up last season. Dude--you are way off base.
As for the rest of this ... I set off world war three about hockey! I love it.
This thread has exploded. Anyway...sorry folks but just because Weinhandl played well with the Sedins 4 years ago, and 9 years ago does not mean he will now. He is nowhere near the player he once was. Jacques Lemaire saw to that. The Sedins never even ask to have him come to Vancouver. Why? Because they know the guys here are better and smarter than he is.
MagJo--Played for the Blackhawks, so yes whoever it was upthread who said he had never played on the small ice...you are wrong. he has. He is just not good. Edler does make mistakes but often they are caused by his d-partners not knowing where to be and the fact that right now he gets 25 minutes of ice time.
What you all have to remember...in the Olympics there are going to be guys (Seabrook, Keith, Niedermeyer, could have been Edler) who have to play 25-30 minutes per game for their teams. IN the Olympics...they will only have to play 20 or so minutes. This will do a few things:
1. Allow them to play at a higher pace, instead of saving themselves for later (niedermeyer, Pronger--older guys)
2. Allow them to play in roles they are more suited to (support guy--IE Edler would have been) instead of as top pair guys.
3. Allow them to be rested a bit and feel better at end of games--Seabrook, Keith who have looked exhausted lately (reason they made the deal for Johnsson)
Oh yeah, MagJo is on that team because Kim JOhnsson said no.
Chemistry from Euro based guys as a helper to team--Sorry not buying this guys. Noone has even half their team from Europe, and they will all be mixed in with the NHLers on their lines. they are not going to play as pairs, or lines...they will get mixed. So that is a load of BS. The reason these guys are here is political..pure and simple. Especially the KHL guys...the Russians are trying to make that league sound like a competitor to NHL, which at this point it is not, save for the old (Jagr), infirm (Emery last season), stupid (Emery last season), and greedy (Radulov). Pure and simple that league is a combindation of old timers and prospects. Just political..that is all.
Same could be said for Sweden. And do you believe for a second honestly that if Forsberg or Naslund had felt healthy, young and capable of doing what they did in the past they would be playing for free in Sweden? No. They go back when they are not able to do what they used to be able to...which makes them inferior players.
Politics rules in hockey everywhere. Especially in Canadian hockey. that is why PRonger is on our team, Weinhandl on Sweden, Magjo on Sweden, and Morozov and others on Russia. C'est rubbish to suggest that these guys will make their teams better than the NHL players. It just is.
Now does that mean they won't win...no. But they will win because of Sedins, or Lidstroms, or Lundqvists Ovechkin, Malkin, Kovalchuk....Gaborik, M Koivu, Kiprusoff, Backstrom, Chara, Halak, dasyuk, Zetterberg....Not the guys who play with them from Europe.
No, you are way off base, because I said the opposite of that, I said that they do know how to play defense.
It was I who said that about Magjo, but if you would actually read the thread you would notice that it has already been covered.
How do you know that players will play just 20 minutes in the Olympics, the top D pairings could still get 25-30 minutes.
Where do you get this politics argument from, I agree that Russia might fall into this category, but most likely the others don't, the players from Europe on those teams have all performed well in international competition, that's why they are on the team. Why do you think that Progner was a "political" decision, you honestly don't think that he is good enough to play for Canada?